photograph courtesy Memphis and Shelby County Room, Memphis Public Libraries
The old Brinkley Female College building as it looked in the mid-1960s. This photograph originally appeared in the Delta Review magazine.
Dear Vance: What became of the young girl who supposedly encountered a ghost at this old college — and for that matter, what happened to the school itself? — R.B., Memphis.
Dear R.B.: The strange events at Brinkley Female College in 1871 created a sensation in Memphis, and newspapers devoted headlines for days to a story with all the elements of a classic Hollywood movie: a haunted mansion, the ghost of a little girl, and a midnight search for buried treasure.
My humble column doesn’t allow space for the complete story, with its baffling twists and turns, but I’ll give a summary before answering your questions.
Let’s start with the location at 683 South Fifth Street. Today that’s a warehouse district, but in 1871, Desoto Street (as it was then called) was a prime residential area lined with grand homes. One of these was the old Davie place, erected by W.J. Davie in 1858.
The two-story mansion, noted for its six fluted columns topped with cast-iron capitals, was home to the Brinkley Female College, a boarding school for some 40 students, advertised as “the largest college in Memphis, and the cheapest in the world.” Perhaps because of its gloomy setting, sitting atop a hill in a grove of ancient trees, or because of the rumor that old man Brinkley (the home’s second owner) had gone insane, the school developed a reputation for being haunted. One that was without basis, it seems, until February 21, 1871.
That Tuesday afternoon, Clara Robertson was practicing her piano lessons in a long hallway upstairs. The daughter of Joseph Robertson, a respected Memphis attorney, the 13-year-old student was later described by reporters as “intelligent and bright beyond her years, and full of simplicity, candor, and truthfulness.”
Pointing out the window, the creature murmured, “Five feet under a stump are valuables that you should have,” looking at Clara. She added, “Don’t be afraid, Clara. My name is Lizzie Davie, and I will not harm you.”
Clara noticed another girl ascend the stairs at the end of the hall and slowly approach her. To her horror, “I saw it was not a living thing.” As reported in the Memphis Avalanche, the apparition was “in the shape of a little girl, with sunken eyes and deep black hair, but virtually a skeleton, clad in a tattered dress of faded pink, covered with a greenish mold.”
At first paralyzed with fear, Clara fled downstairs and breathlessly told fellow students what she’d seen, but she was met with “belief, disbelief, and ridicule.” Those brave enough to venture upstairs saw no trace of the creature.
The next morning, however, Clara was upstairs again, this time with other students and a teacher identified as Miss Jackie Boone, when they heard a curious sound “as if someone were dashing water to the floor.” Turning towards the noise, they saw the ghost at the end of a hallway. Gathering her courage, Clara asked what she wanted. Pointing out the window, the creature murmured, “Five feet under a stump are valuables that you should have,” looking at Clara. She added, “Don’t be afraid, Clara. My name is Lizzie Davie, and I will not harm you.” The teacher claimed she only heard “a rumbling sound,” but the girls said they heard the ghost describing a glass jar, containing deeds and other valuables.
photograph COURTESY MEMPHIS AND SHELBY COUNTY ROOM, MEMPHIS PUBLIC LIBRARY
In the 1960s, the old Davie mansion had fallen on hard times, serving as a tenement house for railroad workers.
The ghost of Lizzie Davie? Old-timers recalled that after the Civil War, one of the young Davie girls had indeed died at a young age, and was buried in a pink dress — contrary to the usual custom that dead children were shrouded in white.
News of these visitations swept the city, and front-page headlines declared, “Brinkley Female College Haunted and in an Uproar of Terror and Confusion.” The Memphis Avalanche called it “the most remarkable ghost story on record.”
This didn’t sit well with the school principal, J.D. Meredith, who told reporters that “it was his firm belief that this visitation was simply an aberration of the mind” and, to put it bluntly, Clara “had no doubt gone crazy.”
Well, there was one good way to prove Clara — and Lizzie — right or wrong: Someone should dig for the treasure. Late on a Sunday night, strong men went to the spot indicated by Lizzie. Any attempts at secrecy vanished when word spread that “they’re digging up the treasure!” and thousands jammed the road in front of the school. After a few hours, however, the searchers found nothing.
Now — if you haven’t decided this already — the story really gets strange. All this time, Clara had sheltered at home, just a few blocks away. As she wandered around her backyard, nervously waiting for news from the diggers, the ghost suddenly materialized before her, instructing her, “You must go and seek the treasure yourself.”
Her family brought her to the college, and the crowd went berserk. “The girl’s here — the girl who saw the ghost!” Sure enough, Clara stepped up to the diggers and told them to search in a different place nearby. This time, shovels crunched against something hard — apparently a brick vault. And lying within ... a glass jar. Inside were bags and packages. Were these the treasures? The mysterious deed?
Well, the entire city would have to wait two months to find out. In another bizarre twist, Clara’s father announced that Lizzie had instructed his daughter to take the jar home and, 60 days later, they would open it on stage at the Greenlaw Opera House. Admission fee: $1 (close to $27 today). The money would compensate the girl for her ordeal, with half going to the Episcopal Church Home for Orphans. The director there declined this offer, saying he wanted nothing to do with “ghost money.”
The Avalanche conveyed the city’s fascination with this bizarre affair: “All day long, and all through the night, the ghost was talked about wherever one chanced to go. Groups discussed the marvelous occurrences at almost every corner of the streets, and various were the theories suggested and the wonderful experiences related.”
The Memphis Daily Appeal proclaimed: “MISS CLARA ROBERTSON has kindly consented to appear upon this occasion in her TRANCE STATE, in which a most angelic expression possesses her, beyond the power of language to describe.”
The “bizarre affair” finally came to an unexpected end. Just a week later, Robertson heard noises in the backyard of his home. He investigated, and a servant found him unconscious, a deep gash in his skull. When a doctor arrived, the attorney said that “four ruffians” had forced him to reveal the glass jar’s hiding place and then slugged him. He had concealed it in a safe place, he said — beneath the seat of the family’s outhouse! The treasure — if that what it was — was gone. No traces of the jar or its belongings were ever seen again.
Right about here, most tellers of this tale bring it to an end, so finally — whew! — I can answer your questions, R.B. The old college closed within a year, unable to endure such a scandal, even after changing its name to Meredith College. After all, what decent family would send their children to a haunted school? The building stood empty before it was converted into a lodging house for railroad workers. It was demolished in 1972. The columns went to a farmer in Arkansas.
This brings us to the fate of Clara Robertson. Many readers assumed that somehow her life returned to normal. Nope. Instead, Clara took to the stage, making public appearances where she told about her encounter with the ghost of Lizzie Davie. Her father published a booklet about the event, selling it after her talks: The Brinkley Female College Story. The Finding of the Mysterious Jar, Its Opening, and Contents. A Thrilling Narrative, Based Upon Facts.
What’s more, Clara began to claim that she was a psychic, and began to hold public seances. Calling it a “Great Attraction!” an advertisement from the May 1, 1871, Memphis Daily Appeal proclaimed: “MISS CLARA ROBERTSON has kindly consented to appear upon this occasion in her TRANCE STATE, in which a most angelic expression possesses her, beyond the power of language to describe.” This would be followed by an “Inspirational Lecture, Given upon the Holy Spirit, Angels, Devils, and Prophecy.”
photograph by vance Lauderdale
ClaraRobertsonGravesite-Elmwood2
Clara’s unmarked gravesite at Elmwood. The gravestone at the right marks the last resting place of Mary Zent, the first wife of John Zent. When he died, he was also buried here, without a tombstone.
By now in her early 20s, she married John Zent, some 30 years older, who had come to Memphis from Philadelphia. He ran a saw mill here, and they moved to an area downtown called the Market Street Slums (demolished for the Lauderdale Courts public-housing project). Clara didn’t live long, dying on November 9, 1883, at age 25 of tuberculosis, during a visit to her father, then living in Wittsburg, Arkansas. She was laid to rest in Elmwood Cemetery, joined there by her husband in 1891, and a son, David, who died in 1940 after working for years as a clerk at Burke’s Book Store.
Anyone visiting the Fowler section of Elmwood would find a small gravestone incribed “Zent.” But that’s for John Zent’s first wife, Mary. Nothing marks the final resting place of Clara Robertson, at one time one of the most famous people in our city.
We’ll never know what really happened at Brinkley Female College in February 1871. Perhaps the whole affair was the desperate scheme of a lonely girl seeking attention. More likely, it was an elaborate hoax, conducted with the help of her father (her mother is never mentioned in the newspaper coverage). But to what end? How did they intend to profit from it — by “setting the stage,” so to speak, for a later career as a psychic and medium?
Whether you believe in ghosts or not, it’s a dramatic story, for sure, but in the end, a sad one.
Got a question for Vance?
MAIL: Vance Lauderdale, Memphis Magazine, P.O. Box 1738, Memphis, TN 38101
EMAIL: askvance@memphismagazine.com
Or visit him from time to time on Facebook.